Suitcases vs backpacks. What works better?

Planning a trip? Picking the best luggage for your travel needs can feel like a make-or-break decision. Both suitcases and backpacks come with their own advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice depends on factors like trip duration, destination and travel habits. Not sure which is best for you? Keep reading…

Benefits of backpacks

• Multi-destination travel: Frequently moving between locations? A backpack provides flexibility and ease, making it perfect for city-hopping, and adventure travel.

• Easy to carry: Getting around with a large suitcase can be frustrating. A backpack lets you move freely, reducing stress when catching flights or making connections.

• Short trips and getaways: Backpacks are especially useful for short trips where you can travel light.

• Budget friendly: Most airlines allow small backpacks as carry-on luggage, helping you avoid extra fees.

• Warm weather destinations: Heading someplace toasty or tropical? A backpack is perfect for carrying light clothing, swimwear and essential accessories without excess weight.

• Accessibility: With a backpack, you can keep your items close, reducing the risk of theft or loss. It also provides quick access to essentials like chargers, travel documents and water bottles.

• Transportation: When rushing to catch a train or bus, a backpack can be the difference between making it or missing it. Having your belongings on your back lets you move faster than when rolling a suitcase.

• Easier to store in hostels and small rooms : Fits in lockers or under hostel beds more easily.

Considerations for backpacks

• Limited space: Not ideal for long-haul travel or colder destinations requiring bulkier clothing.

• Physical strain: Carrying a backpack for extended periods can be tiring and problematic for those with back issues.

• Not weather resistant: Soft shell backpacks can get soaked in rain and are more prone to wear and tear.

• Packing organization: Unlike suitcases, backpacks don’t always allow for neat packing, potentially leading to wrinkled clothes and difficulty finding items.

• Less protection for fragile items : Electronics, souvenirs and toiletries are more likely to get damaged.

Benefits of suitcases

• Versatility: Suitcases are a great pick for both weekend city breaks and long-haul vacations. They have lots of space for all your travel essentials.

• Easy mobility: Four-wheeled suitcases glide smoothly through airports, train stations and hotel lobbies, making them effortless travel companions.

• Less strain on the body: Wheels mean you don’t have to carry heavy loads on your back.

• Weather resistant: A hard shell suitcase protects your stuff from rain and general wear and tear, reducing the risk of damage.

• Packing organization: Suitcases allow for better organization with packing cubes, preventing wrinkled clothes and making it easier to locate items.

• Cold destinations: Heading to a winter destination? A suitcase is better: it has more capacity for thick coats, boots and other bulky items.

• Safety: Laptops, gaming consoles and fragile items are better protected in a suitcase, making it a great for both business and leisure travelers.

• Less hassle for packing liquids: A sturdier exterior reduces the risk of bottles breaking.

Suitcase considerations

• Uneven terrain: Cobblestone streets and rocky paths can make wheeled suitcases hard to handle.

• Limited mobility: A suitcase limits movement in busy areas compared to the ease of carrying a backpack.

• Security: Unlike a backpack that stays on your back, a suitcase is more vulnerable to theft.

• Bulk: If you're frequently changing locations, a suitcase can become a burden.

• Potential fees: Exceeding weight limits can result in costly baggage fees. Check airline luggage size restrictions.

• Not great for stairs : Carrying a suitcase up steps can be a hassle.

• Less flexibility for storage : Doesn’t compress like a backpack to fit into tight spaces.

What to look for in a suitcase or backpack

• Weight : Go for lightweight suitcases or backpacks to avoid unnecessary strain.

• Wheels : Wheeled versions provide maximum convenience.

• Capacity : Pick a size that maximizes space while still meeting airline regulations.

• Material : Consider water-resistant options for added durability.

• Style : Go for a design that reflects your personality and travel needs. While you're here, check out our it Luggage.

Suitcase or backpack? It ultimately depends on the type of trip. If you're traveling light and moving frequently, a backpack is your best bet. Need more packing space and protection for valuables? A suitcase is the better option. Weigh up your priorities, consider your destination, and pick what works best for your travel plans.